Donald Trump's niece's book CAN be published: Judge lifts restraining order on Mary's explosive tell-all just 24 hours after the president's family was granted an injunction
A temporary restraining order blocking the publication of a new tell-all book by President Trump's niece has been lifted by a federal appeals court, one day after the Trump family was granted the preliminary injunction.
A New York court overturned the decision on Wednesday, allowing publisher Simon & Schuster to proceed with the print and distribution of Mary Trump's 'Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World's Most Dangerous Man', due for release on July 28.
Presiding Judge Alan D. Scheinkman noted that, unlike Mary, the company was not bound by a confidentiality agreement and was therefore within their rights to publish the book.
A New York appeals court on Wednesday lifted a temporary restraining order on Mary's book - titled Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World's Most Dangerous Man — is due to come out on July 28
It comes after the Trump family won a preliminary injunction on Tuesday against their niece Mary Trump, blocking publishers from printing and distributing her tell-all book
'While Ms Trump unquestionably possesses the same First Amendment expressive rights belonging to all Americans, she also possesses the right to enter into contracts, including the right to contract away her First Amendment rights,' he said in the ruling.
'Unlike Ms Trump, Simon & Schuster has not agreed to surrender or relinquish any of its First Amendment rights.'
The restraining order remains in place for Mary, but her attorney Ted Boustrous said he plans to file a brief on Thursday for it to be vacated.
Simon & Schuster responded to the appeal in a statement on Wednesday saying: 'We support Mary L. Trump's right to tell her story in Too Much and Never Enough, a work of great interest and importance to the national discourse that fully deserves to be published for the benefit of the American public.'
The restraining order remains in place for Mary, but her attorney Ted Boustrous said in a tweet he plans to file a brief on Thursday for it to be vacated
Presiding Judge Alan D. Scheinkman noted that, unlike Mary, the company was not bound by a confidentiality agreement
It comes just one day after Judge Hal B. Greenwald at the Dutchess County Court sided with the president's younger brother Robert, ordering them to refrain from 'publishing, printing or distributing' any copies of the book ahead of a hearing on July 10.
Robert Trump, 71, argued that Mary's book violated the terms of a confidentiality agreement she signed two decades ago.
Mary is one of two children by Fred Trump Jr, the President's older brother who died in 1981 after battling alcoholism.
The publishing company later told the court they were not aware Mary had signed such an agreement.
Justice Sheinkman, however, said terms could have changed due to her uncle's position as president.
'The legitimate interest in preserving family secrets may be one thing for the family of a real estate developer, no matter how successful. It is another matter for the family of the president of the United States,' he said.
Although the restraining order has been lifted, the Trump family is expected to continue with their battle for an injunction.
The Trumps launched legal action last month over the book by Mary, a psychologist, which the blurb says describes a 'nightmare of traumas, destructive relationships, and a tragic combination of neglect and abuse'.
It is also expected to reveal that Mary was the source of a New York Times investigation into the President in 2018 which demolished his image as a self-made man.
In fact, he received at least $413million from his father and was a millionaire by the time he was eight, she said.
Mary and her brother Fred III had filed suit against Trump, Robert and their sister Maryanne in 2000, for wrongful termination of medical benefits and coverage. When Fred Sr died in 1999, Mary and her brother Fred Trump III challenged his will because they claimed that the Trump family exerted undue influence to cut them out
The Trumps have claimed that she is breaching a non disclosure agreement that she signed 20 years ago to settle a dispute over the will of family patriarch Fred Trump Sr and that they will suffer 'irreparable harm'.
Mary is one of two children by Fred Trump Jr, the President's older brother who died in 1981 in his early 40s after battling alcoholism.
When Fred Sr died in 1999, Mary and her brother Fred Trump III challenged his will because they claimed that the Trump family exerted undue influence to cut them out.
Mary claimed in a lawsuit that in retaliation the Trumps ended healthcare for her side of the family.
In the application for the restraining order the Trumps say that everything was resolved in 2001 under a 'global' agreement.
Donald Trump's niece's book CAN be published: Judge lifts restraining order on Mary's explosive tell-all just 24 hours after the president's family was granted an injunction
Reviewed by CUZZ BLUE
on
July 02, 2020
Rating:
No comments: